The Federal High Court in Sokoto State has dismissed a lawsuit by former African Democratic Congress (ADC) chairman Umar Faruk, who sought to reclaim control of the party’s leadership in the state.
Justice Ahmad Gama delivered the judgment on Friday, ruling that the plaintiffs had failed to provide sufficient grounds to justify their demands. The court resolved all four reliefs sought against them.
Faruk and other party members filed the suit in July over allegations that new members had taken over the ADC’s leadership structure in Sokoto State.
They asked the court to reinstate Faruk as the party’s substantive state chairman. However, their legal challenge failed after the judge examined the arguments presented by both sides.
In his ruling, Justice Gama held that the court could not intervene in the internal affairs of a political party in the circumstances of the case.
The judge also faulted the plaintiffs for approaching the court without first exhausting the party’s internal dispute resolution procedures.
Furthermore, he ruled that they had not established any violation of their fundamental human rights to support their claims.
Reacting to the judgment, counsel to the respondents, Suleiman Usman, SAN, praised the court for what he described as a sound decision.
Usman said the ruling demonstrated the importance of presenting credible evidence when seeking judicial intervention. He maintained that allegations alone could not establish a successful legal claim.
“A litigant cannot win a case without proving it with substantial evidence,” he said.
The senior lawyer added that the judgment would support democratic development by reinforcing respect for due process and the rule of law.
He also argued that the decision had implications beyond the ADC leadership dispute, particularly for Nigeria’s constitutional jurisprudence and democratic institutions.
According to Usman, political disputes must be addressed through established procedures, while parties seeking judicial intervention must provide sufficient evidence to support their demands.
The case stemmed from disagreements over the leadership of the ADC in Sokoto State, with Faruk and the other plaintiffs seeking the court’s intervention to restore the former chairman to his position.
