Manchester City has been a dominant force in English football, winning the Premier League title in four consecutive seasons. Many fans and pundits are beginning to wonder whether their sustained success is turning the Premier League into a “Farmers League”—a term often used to describe leagues with little competition, like Ligue 1 or the Bundesliga. But is City’s dominance actually a bad thing, or are they simply too good for the competition?
READ ALSO: Nigeria Pulls Out From AFCON Qualifier Over Libya Airport Hostage
The Case for City’s Dominance
City’s success is undeniable. Since Pep Guardiola’s arrival in 2016, they’ve raised the standard of football in England, setting record points tallies and redefining what it takes to be champions. In the 2017/18 season, City became the first team in Premier League history to reach 100 points, a feat that highlighted their exceptional quality and work ethic. Other teams struggled to keep up, but that’s more a testament to City’s brilliance than to any faults in the league itself.
Runners-Up Could Have Won in Other Years
A closer look at the Premier League points tallies of teams that finished second to Manchester City provides further evidence of their strength. For example, Liverpool finished with 97 points in 2018/19—an incredible achievement that would have won them the title in almost any other season. City just happened to be historically good that year, finishing with 98 points.
This shows that while City’s dominance is impressive, the competition is not weak. In fact, these second-place teams would likely win titles in other top leagues across Europe. City’s consistency and ability to stay one step ahead of the competition is what sets them apart.
More Than Just Local Dominance
City’s success is not limited to domestic competitions. Their historic treble in 2022/23, where they won the Premier League, FA Cup, and Champions League, solidifies their status as a global powerhouse. While some argue that City’s financial muscle gives them an unfair advantage, it’s clear that their dominance extends beyond English borders.
The notion that City’s success is bad for the Premier League overlooks the fact that they are also flying the flag for English football on the European stage. If anything, City’s success challenges other clubs to step up their game, raising the overall quality of the league.
Is Manchester City Too Good for the Premier League?
Manchester City’s domination stems from a combination of excellent management, a well-executed football philosophy, and financial investment. But this is no different from the dynamics in other top leagues. Real Madrid and Barcelona have traditionally dominated La Liga, Bayern Munich in Germany, and PSG in France. Yet the Premier League still remains highly competitive compared to these leagues because of the depth of its competition.
Rather than “ruining” the Premier League, Manchester City is raising the bar. Other teams now have the opportunity to build their own success in response to City’s challenge. The unpredictability of football means that no team stays on top forever. City’s reign will eventually come to an end, but for now, they’re simply too good.
With Manchester City continuing their dominance, the question remains: who can stop them this season? If you think you’ve got the answer, why not put your predictions to the test with iLOTBET? Register now to bet on all Premier League matches.