Press "Enter" to skip to content

Montreal’s No. 1 restaurant on Tripadvisor did not actually exist

Yoo Jeung has run Le Spot St-Denis, on the nook of Duluth Avenue and St-Denis Road for 22 years. Her flower store is meant to be positioned subsequent to Montreal’s top-rated restaurant on Tripadvisor, Le Nouveau Duluth, however she says she’s by no means heard of it.

She says she is aware of the realm nicely and vacationers usually ask her for instructions to eating places.

“However Novo Duluth? No,” she stated—one thing in regards to the on-line menu sounded to her.

“There’s a very excessive ceiling [in the photos]She stated “In Duluth there aren’t any ceilings excessive…it appears to be like faux.”

The restaurant was on the high of the journey app’s metropolis rankings, however one take a look at its menu was sufficient to show a foodie off.

There isn’t any Le Nouveau Duluth however the ease with which it has risen to the highest of the journey recommendation website is a transparent instance of how simple it’s to create buzz with none substance behind it – and what challenges for actual eating places are noticing within the algorithm.

Woman in a yard, surrounded by lush plants and flowers.
Yoo-jeong’s flower store, Le Spot Saint-Denis, is meant to be positioned subsequent door to Le Nouveau Duluth, however she says she’s by no means heard of it. (Shahrouz Rauf/CBC)

The web page was eliminated after CBC despatched out a request for a response from Tripadvisor. The favored journey web site countered, saying that stunts making a faux restaurant menu have been “unusual occurrences and don’t share the traits of actual rip-off circumstances”.

“On this event, a failure in human moderation practices has resulted within the faux itemizing remaining on the platform longer than it ought to have. The listings – together with feedback and pictures related to the itemizing – are actually inactive.”

To ensure that a restaurant to be listed on Tripadvisor, it should present a cellphone quantity and web site. The URL linked on Le Nouveau Duluth didn’t result in an lively website.

Le Nouveau Duluth has 85 critiques, every giving it 5 stars.

Le Nouveau Duluth restaurant listed on TripAdvisor.
Le Nouveau Duluth was #1 out of three,678 eating places in Montreal in keeping with Tripadvisor. The one downside? It wasn’t actual. (TripAdvisor)

Prime remark headlined “I can not imagine this place really exists.” Most reviewers solely left one evaluate on Tripadvisor – for Le Nouveau Duluth.

The itemizing contained simply 4 images: two exhibiting what regarded like a lounge, certainly one of a sports activities bar and the final of comic Charles Deschamps, whose title is connected to the cellphone variety of the listed restaurant. CBC confirmed that the cellphone makes use of iMessage.

When the CBC examined the Registrar of Firms in Quebec, Le Nouveau Duluth was not included. The situation pin results in the nook of Duluth Road and St-Denis Road, however there is no restaurant referred to as Le Nouveau Duluth in sight.

CBC requested 4 close by firms if they’d heard of Le Nouveau Duluth, together with Le Spot St-Denis. Everybody stated no.

CBC additionally referred to as the quantity listed on the Tripadvisor web page however didn’t obtain a response.

Portrait of a smiling man, leaning against a wall, in the open.
Cybersecurity professional Terry Cutler says it is simple to identify faux critiques as a result of critiques are ambiguous and universally optimistic. (Jennifer Pontarelli)

Counterfeit merchandise are ‘simple to identify’

Though he is by no means come throughout a faux restaurant on Tripadvisor, cybersecurity professional Terry Cutler says it is comparatively simple to identify faux critiques.

“Should you take a look at the critiques,” he stated, “loads of instances they’re very obscure, like ‘Good job,’ ‘hold it on,’ having nothing to do with what the evaluate is about.”

“Should you do not begin to see something however five-star scores—by no means unfavourable critiques—that should be an indication that one thing is fallacious.”

It is simple for anybody to join a bot service, Flood web sites like Google or Tripadvisor with faux critiques, Cutler says, and climb the ranks — on the expense of legit firms.

“Should you actually had five-star restaurant that was within the rankings, now it should take a beating as a result of this faux restaurant is taking on,” he stated.

A woman wearing a black chef's jacket and black apron.  Restaurant tables in the background.
Faux eating places aren’t any joke when it means actual vacationers find yourself within the fallacious place, says Graziella Battista, chef and proprietor of Graziella Restaurant. (submitted by Grazielle Battista)

Menus like Le Nouveau Duluth are “unacceptable,” says Graziella Battista, proprietor of Graziella Restaurant in Previous Montreal.

“After all it is a concern. Individuals who journey rely upon these web sites that evaluate eating places and what sort of locations vacationers go to,” she stated.

Not so way back, Batista famous, eating places earned their scores from well-known restaurant critics reminiscent of “Leslie Chestermans and the all-in-one Marie-Claude Lauretes.”

She additionally famous the existence of a authorities system that ranks establishments with high quality scores. Now, she says, that duty has been transferred to on-line platforms the place “everyone seems to be an professional.”

She says these websites want extra regulation so actual eating places aren’t pushed down the rankings.

Quebec’s Ministry of Tourism says it has no plan to manage on-line restaurant scores or provide a dependable score system for vacationer points of interest.

“It is a hoax,” stated Batista of Le Nouveau Duluth. “You’ll be able to inform once you go to their web page and it is primary in Montreal out of three,670 eating places.”

She says it has grow to be very troublesome to belief data on-line.

“In Options, They Do It All: Ship, Take Out, Reservations, Outside Seating, Buffet, Particular Dinners, Non-public Parking, Have a Full Bar, Wine and Beer, Waterfront, Reside Music, Jazz Bar, It is a Journey – By way of that, they’re on the seashore, they’ve a playground.”

watch | When newspaper restaurant critics prevailed:


What a restaurant critic needs

“I’m primarily in search of freshness,” stated the Globe and Mail reviewer in 1980.



Spread the love