Senators Knock Tinubu’s Gov’t over Borrowing Despite Exceeding Revenue Projections

The Nigerian Senate has expressed concerns over the decision of the Bola Tinubu-led federal government to seek loans to fund the nation’s budgets, despite exceeding revenue projections.

The development comes after revenue-generating agencies, including the Nigeria Customs Service, Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited (NNPCL), and Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS), reported surpassing their 2024 revenue targets.

According to reports, the Nigeria Customs Service generated ₦5.352 trillion, exceeding its ₦5.09 trillion target for 2024. The NNPCL also reported daily oil production of 1.8 million barrels, nearing the 2.06 million barrels per day projected for 2024. The FIRS exceeded its 2024 revenue target of ₦19.4 trillion by 15%, collecting ₦5.7 trillion from company income tax alone.

Despite these impressive revenue performances, the government has secured a $2.2 billion loan (₦1.7 trillion) to partially fund development projects in the 2024 budget.

The move has raised eyebrows among senators, who question the need for borrowing when internally generated revenue appears sufficient to meet the country’s needs.

The lawmakers made their concern known during a session jointly chaired by the Chairman of the Senate Committee on Finance, Sen. Sani Musa, and the Chairman of the House of Representatives Committee on Finance, Hon. James Faleke.

“Why is the government borrowing when we have so much money?” Sen. Adamu Aliero asked.

He added, “From what has been presented to us, all the revenue agencies either met or exceeded their revenue targets. Over ₦51 trillion has been collected so far, while we budgeted about ₦35 trillion for 2024. What are we doing with the excess revenue?”

“Recently, we approved another loan of $2.2 billion.”

Faleke inquired, “If the IGR target has been surpassed, do we still go ahead and borrow simply because it was budgeted?”

Sen. Musa asked, “How will more borrowing help our economy grow?”

Adding to the discourse, Senate Chief Whip, Sen. Mohammed Monguno, expressed dissatisfaction with the “30%” performance of the 2024 budget. According to the lawmaker, that did not justify the revenues and loans secured by the government.

“Budget performance is abysmally 30% as of November, and we are already on the verge of receiving the 2025 budget,” he said with frustration.

The Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister of the Economy, Mr. Wale Edun, defended the government’s decision to borrow, stating that borrowing, when invested for the right purposes, stimulates growth and production.

“Despite the stellar performances of revenue agencies, the revenue is still below the 2024 budget projections because a deficit was already anticipated.

“We still need to improve revenue collection and borrow to invest in the economy to continue stimulating growth and production,” the minister insisted.

Chairman of the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS), Mr. Zacch Adedeji, added that meeting revenue targets did not eliminate the need for borrowing.

“You (the National Assembly) approved in the 2024 budget that we should borrow. The budget includes both borrowing and IGR.

“Borrowing is not a crime. Meeting revenue targets and borrowing are not conflicting,” he stated.

Meanwhile, the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) and the Revenue Mobilisation Allocation and Fiscal Commission (RMAFC) sided with the lawmakers, arguing that Nigeria could fund its budgets without loans.

RMAFC Chairman, Dr. M.B. Shehu, said the NNPCL ceased full payment of petrol subsidies in October but had yet to reconcile remittances to the Federation Account.

“If we become more serious, Nigeria wouldn’t need to borrow a dime at this moment,” he added.

For his take, EFCC Secretary, Mr. Mohammed Haman Joda, announced that the commission successfully recovered ₦197 billion this year. However, he clarified that most of these recoveries were returned to their rightful owners, including state governments. Joda stressed that if revenue agencies were more diligent in their collections, Nigeria’s reliance on borrowing would be significantly reduced. He specifically pointed out that International Oil Companies (IOCs) owe substantial revenues, and urged the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited (NNPCL) to take a stronger stance in addressing this issue.