Why James Gunn's Superman Is Perfect Example Of Non-Toxic Masculine Superhero, According To Expert

James Gunn’s Superman avoids falling into a trap of toxic masculinity, according to an expert. Released this past summer, the DC film introduces David Corenswet as the titular hero, with Rachel Brosnahan playing love interest Lois Lane.

Superman won audiences over for its big action and even bigger heart, but licensed therapist Jonathan Decker now explains on Cinema Therapy that Corenswet’s character is also a perfect example of non-toxic masculinity. One big way Clark displays this, Decker explains, is by being open and honest in his interactions with Lois.

When Clark lays his feelings on the table during an intimate but intense conversation with Brosnahan’s character, this “gives Lois the safety to explore and sort out her feelings without trying to wonder, ‘Where is he at? What’s he thinking? What’s he feeling?’“

Decker and cohost Alan Seawright, a filmmaker, also delve into where Superman’s non-toxic masculinity comes from. It’s a case of “nature versus nuture,” Decker says. As he explains:

“His Kryptonian nature is where all of his powers come from. But his gentleness and his kindness and his regard for human life, this he gets from Jonathan and Martha [Kent].”

The film displays Superman’s non-toxic masculinity in the quiet moments, but it’s also on full display in the fights. Crucially, Decker explains Superman fights not because he wants to, but because he is given no choice:

“Healthy masculinity, when it comes to fighting, is defensive, not aggressive.”

Superman reviews were largely positive, with Gunn’s approach resonating with audiences and critics alike. The colorful visuals, stunning effects, and strong performances are certainly part of the reason for the praise, but Gunn’s script also stresses the power of hope and goodness. This, of course, is in stark contrast to Zack Snyder’s take on Superman, which was far darker and more serious.

Reflecting this positive reception are Superman‘s Rotten Tomatoes scores. The film earned a solid 83% from critics, but the audience-driven Popcornmeter score comes in even higher at 90%. This positive reception paid off at the box office, with the film having grossed $615 million worldwide.

The response to Superman was positive enough to get a sequel greenlit. Gunn is set to write and direct Man of Tomorrow, which is due out in 2027. Though no plot details have been released for this one just yet, the film will presumably once again ensure that Corenswet’s hero is a beacon of hope in the world, displaying a non-toxic kind of masculinity.

With Superman now in the rearview mirror, focus has turned to the next major DC project: the Milly Alcock-starring Supergirl. As revealed in the Superman ending, Alcock’s hero is set to be quite different from Corenswet’s, featuring a rebellious and uncaring attitude. It remains to be seen exactly how the Craig Gillespie 2026 film will compare with Gunn’s, but audiences perhaps shouldn’t expect the same thoughtful displays of masculinity.